Heights 5

Passage:

"Doubtless Catherine marked the difference between her friends , as one came in and the other went out. The contrast resembled what you seein exchanging bleak, hilly, coal country for a beautiful fertile valley; and his voice and greeting were as opposite as his aspect. He had a sweet, low manner or speaking, and pronouced his words as you do: that's less gruff than we talk here, and softer."

This passage shows how Catherine views the two people closest to her. Earlier in the chapter, Nelly informs the reader that Cathy began to "adopt a double character". This passage further supports the idea that Catherine has two opposite parts of her life that she holds seperate from one another. It is clear from this passage that she has slowly forgotten the joy once brought to her from the part of her life that was Heathcliff. It seems as though when she is with Linton (the "beautiful fertile valley"), she attempts to hide any part of her that may not fit in with him. It seems as though she can never truly let herself out when she is around him ( until a few paragraphs later when she hits him). This fact that she always leaves a part of her with Heathcliff ( her true passionate side) leads us readers to hope she will return to him.

The words " as one came in and the other went out" represent more than the character's movement throughout the room - they are showing how Cathy is replacing Heathcliff with Linton. The next few lines continue to compare the two, using words that depict Heathcliff as dark and empty - which is clearly how Cathy views him. She sees Linton as someone who will provide her with wealth and stabilty ("fertile valley") and enjoys feeling as if she can be a part of what he is. She does not think that by being with Heathcliff, she will benefit in any way or gain anything - and these feelings are shown by his being compared to a "bleak, hilly coal country". Coal, however, is something that, while it is dirty, is necessary for energy and survival - maybe this is how Bronte hints at Catherine's attachment to him.